Pros and Cons of Implementing a Points-Based Loyalty Program

Marketers are constantly searching for new ways to attract and retain customers. Often, this involves using tried and true loyalty marketing methods.

From offering discounts on popular items to “buy-one-get-one-free” sales, marketing professionals typically stick with what works. However, these approaches can be costly. If the boost in sales doesn’t make up for the lost revenue, the programs can hurt, rather than help, the company. A points-based customer loyalty program offers a compelling, yet cost-effective driver of sales for any business.

How it works

The concept of the program is simple. Every time a customer or employee completes a qualifying activity, they earn a specified number of points. They are able to easily track the number of points they have earned throughout their time as a customer of the business. The prospect of earning even more points draws them back in.

Eventually, whenever the participant earns enough points, they can redeem them for a reward of some kind. This could include prepaid Visa cards, gift cards, digital rewards, goods, and services from the issuing organization. Other organizations may award participants in their points-based customer loyalty program bonus products.

In addition to driving repeat sales, these programs also create new channels through which organizations can reach new customers. To earn points, customers often need to submit their email address or phone number and opt-in to communications from the business. Once customers submit their contact information, businesses are free to send marketing communications to them by text or email. Organizations can use this data to inform participants in their points-based customer loyalty program of events such as new product launches, upcoming sales, and the opening of new locations.

Perhaps the best endorsement of these programs is their widespread adoption across a range of industries and for a variety of use cases. These loyalty programs are a staple for market research, automotive, health & wellness, and sales incentives to mention a few.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Customer Loyalty Programs

Before launching a points-based customer loyalty program, it’s worth knowing how they can benefit a company. Here are a few of them.

Pros of a Points-Based Loyalty Program

Encourages Repeat Purchases Points-based loyalty programs provide an incentive for customers to keep coming back. Each time they make a purchase, they earn points, which makes customers more likely to continue shopping with your brand to redeem those points for rewards. According to studies, businesses with loyalty programs see up to a 20% increase in repeat purchases.
Flexibility in Rewards A points system allows businesses to offer a variety of rewards, from discounts and free products to exclusive experiences or services. This flexibility means you can tailor the rewards to your specific customer base, enhancing satisfaction and engagement.
Increases Customer Engagement By offering points for actions like signing up, referring friends, or leaving reviews, a points-based loyalty program can foster greater customer interaction with your brand. More engagement means more opportunities for your business to build strong relationships with customers and increase brand loyalty.
Valuable Customer Insights A points-based loyalty program provides valuable data about customer purchasing behavior. This data can be used to refine marketing strategies, personalize offers, and improve the overall customer experience, creating a more efficient business model.

Cons of a Points – Based Loyalty Program

Can Be Complex to Manage One potential downside of a points-based loyalty program is that it can become complicated to manage, especially as your customer base grows. Points need to be tracked accurately, and clear communication with customers about point accrual and redemption is essential to avoid confusion. Implementing robust software, like our RewardSTACK™ platform, can alleviate these challenges.
Risk of Customer Apathy While points-based loyalty programs can drive engagement, there is a risk that customers might lose interest if the rewards are perceived as too difficult to achieve or not valuable enough. It’s crucial to find the right balance between points earned and rewards offered to keep customers motivated.
Possible Cost of Rewards Running a points-based loyalty program involves costs, including the rewards themselves and any administrative fees associated with tracking and distributing points. Businesses must carefully calculate whether the long-term benefits, such as increased customer retention, outweigh the initial and ongoing costs.
Potential for Fraud There’s a risk that loyalty points could be misused or fraudulently redeemed. This is why it’s essential to have strong security measures in place when implementing a points-based program. Using a reputable platform with built-in fraud prevention features can mitigate this risk.

Is a Points-Based Loyalty Program Right for You?

While there are challenges to implementing a points-based loyalty program, the potential benefits in customer retention and increased engagement can outweigh the drawbacks. With proper management, a points-based system can provide flexibility and valuable insights into customer behavior, helping businesses grow.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. What is a points-based loyalty program?
A points-based loyalty program is a system where customers earn points for every purchase or action taken, which can later be redeemed for rewards such as discounts, free products, or exclusive experiences.

2. How do points-based loyalty programs increase customer retention?
By offering rewards for repeat purchases or engagement, points-based loyalty programs incentivize customers to return and accumulate more points, increasing overall retention and loyalty.

3. What are the typical costs of running a points-based loyalty program?
The costs include the value of rewards, management software, and potential administrative fees. However, many businesses find that the increase in customer retention and repeat sales outweighs the costs.

4. How do you prevent fraud in points-based loyalty programs?
Strong security measures, such as verification processes and using robust loyalty platforms like RewardSTACK™, can help prevent fraud and ensure points are only redeemed by the rightful customer.

Final Thoughts

Implementing a points-based loyalty program offers exciting possibilities for increasing customer loyalty and retention but requires careful planning and management. You can determine if this approach aligns with your business goals by weighing the pros and cons. If you’re ready to take the next step, our team at All Digital Rewards is here to help you create a successful, secure, customizable loyalty program that works for you. Call us now at 866-415-7703!

Click here to learn more about the Key Components of a Successful Loyalty Program

The Ezeprepaid™ Visa Prepaid Card and Ezeprepaid™ Visa Virtual Account are issued by The Bancorp Bank, N.A.; Member FDIC, pursuant to a license from Visa U.S.A. Inc. Purchase, acceptance or use of the card constitutes acceptance of the Cardholder Agreement and Virtual Accountholder Agreement. The Visa Virtual Account may be used for electronic commerce, mail order and/or telephone order transactions everywhere Visa debit cards are accepted. The Visa Prepaid Card may be used everywhere Visa debit cards are accepted. The Bancorp Bank, N.A. does not endorse or sponsor, and is not affiliated in any way with this offer.